Best Eye Primers for Mature Skin that Keep You Looking Fresh

Home » Makeup » Best Eye Primers for Mature Skin

Are you tired of spending hours polishing your eye makeup just to notice that it creases or disappears after a few hours? Well, aging is not a pleasant experience. As you get older, your bodies’ estrogen levels decrease, causing your skin to dry and lose suppleness.

Moreover, there comes the unpleasant presence of wrinkles and fine lines, which always ruin your day. You may also notice that your skin is not as flawless and radiant as it once was, specifically around your eyes. Truly, these things could be quite frustrating.

Fortunately, the best eye primers for mature skin not only help makeup last all day but also prevent them from setting into your fine lines and wrinkles. The even better news is, numerous primers are particularly developed for aging skin, thus they make your skin appear younger and smoother.

If you find these best-rated eye primers for mature skin interesting, continue reading to know about the ones that are gentle on aging skin and provide a perfect finish. And later, I will give you some in-depth guidelines on how you can select the right eye primer that complements your needs.

Milani Eyeshadow Primer
Top Pick
Milani Eyeshadow Primer
9.8
  • 8-hour makeup protection
  • Enhances eyeshadow vibrancy
  • Crease-proof formulation
  • Lightweight
  • Vegan 
Elizabeth Mott Thank Me
Runner Up
Elizabeth Mott Thank Me
9.6
  • Minimizes wrinkles
  • Locks in eye makeup
  • Matte finish
  • Contains pearl powder
  • Evens skin tone
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Eyeshadow Base Primer
Best for Dry Skin
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Eyeshadow Base Primer
9.6
  • Leaves a smooth canvas
  • Maintains makeup vibrancy
  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free
  • Suitable for dry skin
DHC Velvet Skin Coat, Mattifying Makeup Primer
DHC Velvet Skin Coat, Mattifying Makeup Primer
9.6
  • Contains olive fruit oil
  • Reduces fine lines and wrinkles
  • Conceals age spots
  • Long-lasting
  • Contains silica
Urban Decay Anti-Aging Eyeshadow Primer
Urban Decay Anti-Aging Eyeshadow Primer
9.5
  • Formulated for mature skin
  • Contains Kalpariane
  • Includes Rice Bran Oil
  • Infused with Beeswax
  • Ideal for dry skin
Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer
Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer
9.5
  • Locks in eye makeup
  • Color correcting feature
  • Conceals discolorations
  • Includes botanical ingredients
  • Good for a no-makeup makeup look
Too Faced Shadow Primer
Too Faced Shadow Primer
9.5
  • All-around primer
  • Ensures a long-lasting makeup
  • Fills in wrinkles
  • No harmful chemicals
  • Ideal for sensitive skin
SmashBox Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye Primer
SmashBox Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye Primer
9.2
  • Good for dry skin
  • Hydrating formula
  • Versatile primer
  • Crease-resistant formula
  • Keeps eye makeup vibrant
bareMinerals Prime Time Eye Primer
bareMinerals Prime Time Eye Primer
9.2
  • Does not smudge
  • Keeps makeup intact
  • Prevents excess sebum
  • Lightweight
  • Crease-free
Monica Ann Beauty Dual-Action Eye Shadow Primer
Monica Ann Beauty Dual-Action Eye Shadow Primer
9.2
  • Leaves a radiant finish
  • Infused with hyaluronic acid
  • Contains vitamin C
  • Oil-free
  • No harmful ingredients

1. Milani Eyeshadow Primer

Milani Eyeshadow Primer
Pros
  • Protects your eye makeup and prevents it from smudging for up to 8 hours
  • Enhances the vibrant colors of your eyeshadow
  • Gives your eyelids a youthful look
  • Crease-proof formulation
  • Beige shade; lightweight and non-sticky texture
Cons
  • Applying a huge amount might result in caking

In terms of increasing the longevity of your eyeshadow while keeping wrinkles away, this Milani eyeshadow primer is the gold standard. It is popular among cosmetics enthusiasts of all ages. This primer is a must-have in your makeup collection if you want to protect your eye makeup, keeping it fresh for up to 8 hours without smudging!

Aside from that, I like how this primer enhances the vivid shade of your eyeshadow, whether it is a dramatic shimmering eye or a basic pinkish neutral appearance. It gives your eyelids a more youthful and less dreary look. I love wearing eyeshadow daily so this eye primer is one of my favorite makeup essentials for fresh and vibrant eyeshadows.

In addition to that, creasing could exacerbate wrinkles and fine lines that you are attempting to conceal. Fortunately, this high-quality eye primer with a crease-proof formulation addresses these skin issues. Plus, this vegan and cruelty-free primer has a beige shade that dries purely unnoticeable, making it ideal for all types of complexion.

Although it has a lightweight and non-sticky texture, you must be careful not to apply too much of this eye primer to your eyelids as it may cake, resulting in an unappealing appearance.

>> Click here to buy now

2. Elizabeth Mott Thank Me

Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Primer
Pros
  • Solves fine lines and wrinkles in a breeze
  • Locks in eyeshadow makeup
  • Dries to a matte finish in just seconds
  • Contains pearl powder to control oil
  • Evens out your skin tone
Cons
  • The primer is hard to remove

You will probably agree that our skin can be vulnerable to oiliness and smudging makeup because of fine lines and wrinkles. Well, If you are like me who has been experiencing these skin issues, this Elizabeth Mott primer is among favorite picks for oil-free and smudge-free applications.

This well-known eye primer seals in your bright eyeshadows around your eyes, ensuring that your appearance will last the whole day. It is ideal for special occasions since it prevents your eye makeup from fading and disappearing. Moreover, it settles to a matte sheen in seconds after applying, which will help you get your makeup started right away.

Aside from that, this formulation offers a flawless base on your eyelid, enabling you to apply eye makeup without creases. This features pearl powder, which helps in controlling excessive production of sebum and balancing out your skin tone. Since the formulation is lightweight and non-oily, putting it onto your lids will not be bothersome.

The drawback is that it requires a long time to erase the primer. Hence, you will need more than just a basic face wash to do that. To clear the remaining residue, you will need to use a more intense makeup cleanser.

>> Click here to buy now

3. DHC Velvet Skin Coat

DHC Velvet Skin Coat Primer
Pros
  • Contains olive fruit oil for maximum hydration
  • Minimizes fine lines and wrinkles
  • Conceals blemishes, age spots, and scars
  • Long-lasting
  • Infused with silica to combat oil
Cons
  • Not that ideal for dry skin

DHC’s Velvet Skin Coat has been one of my top go-to eye primers because of its natural ingredients that are safe for the skin. It has olive fruit extract, an organic moisturizer, that helps turn your skin into a silky smooth surface while minimizing the appearance of fine lines, creases, and wrinkles for speedy and effortless eye makeup.

You can conceal all of your blemishes, age spots, and scars by using this high-quality eye primer for mature skin. The matte sheen lasts for hours, allowing your makeup to appear radiant and gorgeous the whole day. If you are always present at special events and want to maintain the vibrancy of your eye makeup, I will recommend buying this primer.

Moreover, this eye primer can help in fighting skin oiliness as it includes silica. It is free of harmful colorants and fragrances, making it suitable for all sensitive skin types.

The downside, nevertheless, is that it is not ideal for mature women with dry skin. Its matte finish will not appear pleasantly on that skin type.

>> Click here to buy now

4. Urban Decay

Urban Decay Primer
Pros
  • Specially formulated for mature skin
  • Contains Kalpariane to improve hydration and skin elasticity
  • Patented polymer formula for smooth makeup base
  • Stimulates better cell renewal
  • Infused with rice bran oil and beeswax
Cons
  • Not that ideal for oily skin

This Urban Decay eye primer is exclusively made for anti-aging purposes, so your mature skin will appreciate this eye primer. It uses a patented polymer formula to deliver a seamless base for your eye makeup. Plus, it contains Kalpariane, which works to moisturize and firm up the skin, making it more elastic and hydrated.

Dermaxyl, one of the eye primer’s outstanding properties, effectively evens out creases, fine lines, and other indications of aging skin. Additionally, it aids in natural skin barrier restoration and stimulates better cell renewal in mature skin. I bet you will look a lot younger if you are going to regularly use this eye primer!

Another distinctive aspect that I love of is the inclusion of optical blurring agents, which brighten your eyes by reducing dullness and inflammation. It also contains rice bran oil and beeswax for maximum skin hydration. Aside from that, the primer dries with a translucent shade, making it suitable for all skin tones.

On the other hand, due to its strong hydrating properties, its consistency could be slightly greasy, which is not that ideal for oily skin.

>> Click here to buy now

5. NYX PROFESSIONAL

NYX PROFESSIONAL Primer
Pros
  • Ideal for dry skin
  • Provides a very smooth and consistent canvas
  • Keeps your makeup vibrant 
  • Extends the longevity of your eye makeup
  • Vegan
Cons
  • Applying large amounts will result in caking and smudging

This ultra-smooth eye primer delivers a satin-smooth, consistent canvas for your whole face. The formula is somewhat slicker to allow easier distribution on dry skin, which is common in mature women. That is why I find this eye primer effective on dry skin.

Furthermore, this primer ensures that your makeup is as vibrant as possible. During the day, your makeup shades will remain rich and appealing. It holds all of your eye makeup in position, whether it is colorful shadows or vintage black winged eyeliner.

Aside from that, this eye primer renders your eye makeup water-resistant, which helps it stay far longer than your typical primer. This implies you can do chores in the rain and your makeup will still appear flawless hours later. This product is completely vegan and guaranteed cruelty-free.

On the flip side, you have to be certain that you will get a sufficient amount of the product on your initial stroke because if you add more after it sets, it becomes heavy and cakey.

>> Click here to buy now

6. Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer

Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer
Pros
  • Holds your eyeliner and eyeshadow for hours
  • Color correcting function
  • Resists creases
  • Conceals redness, blotches, and other discolorations
  • Great for a no-makeup makeup look
Cons
  • Thick consistency; hard to spread

Laura Mercier’s eye primer is exceptional at holding your eyeliner and eyeshadow in position, crease-free, and looking healthy the whole day. I have tested this eye primer before and the color-correcting feature is definitely a nice base to apply eye makeup evenly. Plus, it blends quickly, resists creases, and does not slip off from your eyelids.

Aside from that, this dermatologist-tested primer conceals redness, blotches, and various dark spots. It contains an exquisite combination of botanicals and various skin-friendly components that helps relieve and safeguard your eyelids’ vulnerable skin.

Furthermore, you can use this waterproof primer as your eye makeup alone if you want to achieve a natural no-makeup makeup look. It also balances out your skin tone and makes it look more youthful and healthy. I think this would be an ideal selection if you are not fond of applying colored eyeshadows on your eye area and want to protect it only.

The only issue with this primer is its thick consistency, which makes it hard to spread on your eye area.

>> Click here to buy now

7. Too Faced Shadow

Too Faced Shadow Primer
Pros
  • You can apply it on your eyebrows, eyelashes, and under your hairline
  • Ensures a long-lasting makeup
  • Fills in wrinkles and fine lines
  • Free of harmful cosmetic chemicals
  • Great for sensitive skin
Cons
  • Does not last long on oily skin

This primer by Too Faced incredibly prolongs the longevity and vivid hues of your eye makeup. It seems true because I noticed that it did not wear out quickly after hours of application. I also like how you can apply it safely on your eyebrows, eyelashes, and underneath your hairline.

Furthermore, this primer contains silicones, which offer a flawless canvas for your makeup application to occupy wrinkles and fine lines, reducing their unsightly appearance. Hence, your concealer and eyeshadows will not sit into the wrinkles and fine lines.

Truly, this primer is safe to use as it is free of cosmetic chemicals that might trigger skin aggravation, including phthalates, sulfates. and parabens. If you have sensitive skin, I think this would be a suitable option.

The only drawback of this primer is that it only suppresses oil production for a brief period. So if you have oily skin, this might not be a smart option.

>> Click here to buy now

8. SmashBox Photo Finish Primer

SmashBox Photo Finish Primer
Pros
  • Versatile primer
  • Ideal for dry skin
  • Hydrating formula
  • Keeps your eye makeup vibrant
  • Crease-proof formula
Cons
  • Relatively expensive

Since SmashBox is one of the most well-known brands in high-end cosmetics, their formulations are generally quite flexible and can fix more than one skin problem. And that is exactly what this eye primer is. It is multipurpose as you can use it as an effective primer for your eyelid and under-eye area as well.

Aside from that, if you are dealing with skin dryness, I believe you will also appreciate the benefits of this primer. It features a moisturizing formulation that gently hydrates the skin around your eyes, allowing it to look youthful and vibrant even as you become older.

Furthermore, this primer keeps your eye makeup—whether eyeliner or concealer—in position. It resists fading throughout the day, allowing your makeup to remain fresh. It also boasts a crease-proof composition, so no smudging makeup and unwanted fine lines will occur.

The issue, nevertheless, is its price, which is a bit more expensive than the other primers on this list.

>> Click here to buy now

9. BareMinerals Primer

BareMinerals Primer
Pros
  • Does not smudge
  • Helps eye makeup remain intact all-day
  • Prevents excessive sebum production
  • Lightweight and smooth texture
  • Prevents eyeshadows from creasing
Cons
  • Low-quality packaging

This amazing eye primer from Bare Minerals holds your makeup in place the entire day without smudging and creeping around your eye region to produce a sloppy mess. Impressively, this primer is one of the best picks I found that can help eyeshadows last throughout the day.

Furthermore, I admire how this primer minimizes unnecessary sebum production on the lids, preventing you from looking greasy. It mattifies your skin and allows your makeup to appear precise and dramatic. The primer has a smooth texture that feels extremely light on the lids and never feels cakey or thick.

Apart from that, it produces a consistent base on your face, preventing eyeshadows from creasing, especially if you have a lot of wrinkles around your eyes or hooded eyelids.

The only downside of this eye primer is its low-quality packaging. The tip easily detaches from the primer tube. If you are not careful when squeezing it, it could create a mess on your hand.

>> Click here to buy now

10. Monica Ann Beauty

Monica Ann Beauty Primer
Pros
  • Gives your eye makeup a radiant finish
  • Acts as a great base for your makeup
  • Contains hyaluronic acid
  • Contains vitamin C
  • Oil-free
Cons
  • Leaves a slightly sticky feeling

One of the reasons why I like this Monica Ann Beauty primer is its one-of-a-kind formulation that can deliver a radiant finish in your eyeshadows. It features skin-nourishing components that nurture the sensitive skin around your eyes while also acting as an excellent base for your vivid eye makeup.

Since this great primer includes skin-treating ingredients such as hyaluronic acid and vitamin C, you can counteract discoloration and plump skin to lessen the sight of fine wrinkles while keeping your skin well-hydrated. Honestly, I do not always find good eye primers infused with Vitamin C that can refine skin tone and eliminate dark spots. So having these benefits in a product that I can use every day is quite a treat.

Additionally, this smooth, oil-free, and sweat-proof primer replenishes your eye area with harmless and approved ingredients to assist you in achieving stunning eye makeup look without compromising the quality of your natural skin.

On the contrary, it kind of falls short in terms of its consistency, which is quite thick. Hence, it leaves a slightly sticky feeling.

>> Click here to buy now

How To Choose Best Eye Primers For Mature Skin

Lightweight Formula to Fully Prevent Creasing

Thick eye primers sit awkwardly and emphasize the look of wrinkles and fullness in mature skin. Furthermore, no one wants to feel any additional heaviness on their eyelids.

Yes, lightweight formula is a critical factor to consider when searching for an eye primer for older eyes. Plus, it optimizes the eye primer’s ability to avert creases. And because they apply uniformly and offer a seamless canvas, they frequently necessitate less amount of primer for more thorough coverage.

Smudge-free

The more creases and lines around your eyes, the more quickly your eyeshadow will smudge. Once you have overlooked checking the condition of your eyeshadow, you can acquire cluttered and messy-looking eye makeup a few hours later.

That is why it is critical to invest in an eye primer that can keep your makeup in place. If you want your eyeshadow to last for an extended period, you should use a well-adhering yet light-formula primer to keep it in place.

Protects Your Eye Makeup and Skin for 24 Hours

Another significant feature to look for in an eye primer is a 24-hour wear assurance. The more activities you do, the older your look may become. Whether you are balancing your job, house, or children, indeed, the majority of your time is often allocated for responsibilities that need you to appear presentable.

Hence, make sure to get yourself an eye primer that will work for you long-term, so you can persistently continue with your tasks without worrying about the condition and appearance of your eye area from time to time.

Infused with Hydrating and Skin-Treating Properties

You must be more mindful of beauty products that might damage your skin as you mature, such as pore-clogging creams and cleansers. When it pertains to primers, it is a definite advantage if the formulation includes skin-treating and hydrating compounds that enrich the health, condition, and look of your mature skin.

Always go for primers with hydrating properties such as Shea butter and coconut milk to moisturize the skin and make it appear youthful and fresher. You can also look for primers enriched with vitamin E if your dry and flaky skin needs a boost of suppleness.

Keeps Your Skin Tone Even and Flawless

Your eye area is often darker than the remainder of your face’s complexion. If you do not cover your eye area well, you might look fatigued and restless. That is why it is critical to search for a primer that can assist in balancing out your skin tone and making it seem flawless.

Certain primers feature a minimal beige tone to help conceal blemishes including redness and puffiness, making you appear more refreshed and evenly toned. No doubt the colors will look more stunning and intensified once you apply a colored eyeshadow on your smoother and more even-toned eye area.

Completely Fills in Wrinkles and Fine Lines

Whenever you apply eye makeup on older women, wrinkles and fine lines could be some of the most common concerns. The more wrinkles you have, the more easily your eye makeup will crease. Eyeshadow can sit in wrinkles, forming unsightly lines, making your eye makeup seem disheveled.

Thus, you must ascertain your eye primer contains crease-fighting components for your makeup to go on seamlessly and not wrinkle or break. Not only will your eye makeup seem more fashionable, but you will also look younger as your wrinkles and fine lines become well-covered and drastically reduced.

Combats Oiliness

Excessive sebum production, often known as oiliness, is yet another factor that makes makeup smear more easily over mature, wrinkled eyelids. Search for an eye primer that dries into a matte finish to help you control your oil production and prolong your makeup.

However, if you have dry skin in the first place, you might not need to use a matte primer. On the other hand, a very dry eyelid might cause the eyeshadow to crack and crease.

Enhances the Appearance of Your Eyeshadows

Due to their strong and vibrant hues, eyeshadows are arguably the most enthusiastic feature of your glamorous appearance. Hence, you do not want them to fade and disappear after applying them. 

That is why it is essential to search for an eye primer that will enhance your eyeshadows and make them pop and glow even after a long day. Colors that flare allow for a vibrant appearance, so make the most of your colorful, eye-catching makeup.

How To Apply Eye Primer on Mature Skin

Incorporating an eye primer into your makeup regimen is practical. Basically, you will apply a pea-sized amount to your eyelids shortly after you have finished hydrating your skin. After patting it into your wrinkles and achieving a smooth base, add your eye makeup.

However, you can read below to know the step-by-step instructions on how to apply eye primer on mature skin.

  • Wash your skin to remove any pollutants.
  • Apply toner onto your face, but mainly focus on your eye area. This is the first step of hydrating your skin.
  • Hydrate your face with your selected moisturizer to guarantee hydration and skin preparation.
  • Apply a pea-sized portion of your eye primer under your eyes very carefully and dab it. To mix it in, use your fingertips quite gently. When using a powder primer, dab it lightly under your eyes with your applicator.
  • If necessary, use concealer to cover any flaws. If you do not have any skin blemishes to conceal, finish by applying your foundation.
  • Put on your eye makeup.
  • Finally, apply some setting powder or setting spray onto your face for added skin and makeup protection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does eye primer help with wrinkles?

Yes, using an eye primer can help in the minimization of wrinkles. It covers up unattractive lines and wrinkles around your eyes and functions as a canvas for your eye makeup, allowing it to last longer. Aside from that, primers give your skin a more youthful appearance.

Is there a difference between face primer and eye primer?

A face primer is for your entire face, whereas an eye primer is exclusively developed and formulated to address skin issues around your area.

Can I use eyeshadow primer under my eyes?

You can apply an eyeshadow primer under your eyes to help your eye makeup last longer. Eyeshadow primer can have two functions when applied under your eyes. First, it can extend the longevity of your concealer and prevent it from creasing.

Because eye primers avert your eyeshadows from wrinkling, the same concept holds for the skin under your eyes. Second, since it makes shadows adhere effectively, your concealer will cling better and last much longer as well.

What is the difference between eye primer and concealer?

The first step in your makeup procedure should always be the application of primer. Apply your primer once you have applied your moisturizer. It will hide any noticeable wrinkles and fine lines. Primer gives your foundation and concealer a smooth canvas to work upon. It also increases the longevity of your makeup.

On the other hand, you will only apply concealer on your face or eye area once you have finished applying your primer. The purpose of applying concealers is to cover your red spots and dark circles. You can only wear concealer after applying your primer.

How do primers help hide wrinkles on more mature eyelid skin?

High-quality and well-formulated eye primers effectively fill in fine lines and wrinkles that occur as your skin gets mature. Since the primer fills in these openings, your cosmetics will no longer settle and sit in them and produce unsightly marks, resulting in minimal to zero creases.

When you apply an exceptional eye primer, you will notice that many of your fine lines, creases, and wrinkles vanish immediately, obscuring your actual age. Moreover, you will have a seamless and faultless base on which to put eye makeup properly and look a lot more youthful.

How does mature eyelid skin differ from that of younger people?

Youthful skin is more inclined to be flexible and smooth since it is always properly hydrated and nourished. Furthermore, it has minimal wrinkles and fine lines since younger individuals have not yet experienced the wear and tear of daily lifestyle that only mature people experience.

On the contrary, older skin is much drier since it is no longer inherently hydrated. Aside from that, it also has fine lines, wrinkles, and age spots, particularly around the eyes.

The undesirable appearance of crow’s feet could develop on the corners of each eye area of a mature individual. Wrinkles also cause additional creases in the eyes, allowing their makeup to scatter and smear easily. Eyelids can also get cakey, which is why there are treatments including eye primers for mature skin that can treat these very particular skin issues.

Conclusion

Having mature skin is not easy. However, combating eye wrinkles, creases, age spots, and fine lines does not always necessitate an appointment with your dermatologist or local cosmetic surgeon.

No wrinkles and fine lines can damage your flawless and stunning eyeshadow appearance if you use the best eye primers for mature skin. Indeed, you can always reestablish your blemish-free appearance while also hydrating your beloved skin. Using an eye primer is a vital key for feeling more confident about your eye appearance and overall getup, even if you have mature skin.

Hopefully, the top picks and their reviews, as well as the buying guide mentioned above, will help you find the most effective and reliable eye primer for your mature skin. And once you find the right primer for you, purchase it right away, apply it on your skin, and no doubt, you can achieve glamorous eye makeup that will make you feel gorgeous.

Leave a Comment