Best Eyeliner for Older Women – Easy-Glide, Smudge-Free, Long-Lasting

Home » Makeup » Best Eyeliner for Older Women

When the skincare routine changes as you grow older, why shouldn’t your makeup routine have to go through the same? So maybe it’s time to switch to the best eyeliner for older women. This kind, specifically formulated for mature skin, consists of a few unique qualities. Such as it being hypoallergenic, waterproof, quicker to dry, easier to apply, and more.

These special qualities are given extra attention of course in the case of the best eyeliner for over 50. And it’s necessary for older women to bring about this change in their makeup and skincare routine to ensure that the face looks more radiant and youthful.

More importantly, such factors make sure that your makeup feels comfortable and looks well-defined and complete. So let’s have a look at the best eyeliner picks that do not create uneven lines, gapping, and the like for women over 50 years of age!

Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil
Top Pick
Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil
  • 24-hour wear, waterproof pencil eyeliner
  • Smooth, creamy, smudge-proof
  • Dual-sided with built-in smudger and sharpener
Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner
Runner Up
Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner
  • Gel liner precision and ease of use
  • Color emollients/waxes stay on for 12 hours, smudge-free
  • Silky-soft, creamy texture
Almay AllDay Intense Gel Eyeliner
Almay AllDay Intense Gel Eyeliner
  • Hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, cruelty-free
  • Rich and creamy with intense, all-day color
  • Smudge-proof, waterproof, and it dries instantly
stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
  • Super-fine micro-tip for more precision/control
  • Very dark, goes on smoothly, and dries quickly
  • Suitable for oily lids and beginners
L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner
L’Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner
  • Mineral-pigmented eyeliner for sensitive, aging eyes
  • Tug-free tip + rubber grip enables easy, quick application
  • Waterproof, super-smooth, and lasts all-day
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
  • Perfect for hooded eyelids
  • Long-wearing, intense, waterproof color
  • Ultra-creamy with moisturizing ingredients
Estee Lauder Eye Care Double Wear Stay In Place Eye Pencil
Estee Lauder Eye Care Double Wear Stay In Place Eye Pencil
  • Super-smooth, creamy eyeliner pencil
  • Clean line glides on very easily
  • Stays smudge-free and true to color all-day
Clinique Quickliner for Eyes
Clinique Quickliner for Eyes
  • Best eyeliner for ease of application
  • Silky, smooth texture glides on effortlessly
  • Handy smudger included
Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil
Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil
  • Soft, gentle, easy-to-glide-on pencil eyeliner
  • Enriched with nourishing rainforest shea butter and olive oil
  • Non-fading, non-smudging with subtle light diffusers (so eyes appear whiter)
Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner
Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner
  • Water-resistant powder-based creamy eyeliner
  • Formulated with coco glycerides for smooth application
  • Dip pull-out applicator brush in the lid

1. Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil

Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil
  • A classic, long-wear, waterproof pen eyeliner
  • Creamy, smooth glide (tug-free)
  • Sharpener and smudger built into the product
  • All 8 shades are ophthalmologist-tested
  • Tip tends to break off when pressed too hard
  • Sharpening this pencil clogs up the sharpener

Best long-lasting eyeliner for mature eyes despite being the pencil kind. Even if you have oily lids, Revlon Colorstay really STAYS without smearing, smudging, or bleeding.

It’s a cult-classic, 24-hour wear, waterproof formula that glides on so smoothly that your extra sensitive or delicate skin around your eyes doesn’t get pulled or tugged at all. Thanks to the creamy texture!

2. Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner

Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner
  • Very soft, lightweight, creamy texture
  • Glides on very easily without stretching eyelid
  • No need to sharpen but it comes with a sharpener
  • Humidity-resistant, sweat-resistant, and waterproof
  • Not for oily lids
  • Takes a long time to dry

Bobby Brown’s Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner is hugely popular, despite its extra price, simply because of its liquid precision and ease of use since it’s gel-based. Plus, sweat-resistant, waterproof, and 12-hour wear!

Very pliable and soft, thus no need to stretch your eyelids and skin. And you can easily and completely blend this thing using a brush or your finger. The vibrancy of those saturated pigments (comes in 3 different colors) remains intact for as long as 12 hours, without smudging, fading, or flaking.

3. Almay AllDay Intense Gel Eyeliner

Almay AllDay Intense Gel Eyeliner
  • Fragrance-free hypoallergenic eyeliner
  • Waterproof, fade-proof gel-based formula
  • 24-hour long wear and glides on very easily, smoothly
  • You run through gel liners very fast
  • Very difficult to sharpen

Now how about the best hypoallergenic eyeliner, or more specifically, the best hypoallergenic gel eyeliner. AllDay Intense by Almay – the two words ‘AllDay’ and ‘Intense’ are quite descriptive when it comes to defining the character of this eyeliner that women in their 50s highly recommend.

When you get older, your lids begin to become less firm. Hence, the want for a liner that glides right on and doesn’t tug or skip. After all, this is a very smooth and creamy gel-based formula. Plus, it’s free of harsh/harmful substances like phthalates, SLS, parabens, triclosan, formaldehyde, and more. Like I said, best for sensitive eyes!

4. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
  • Easy-to-apply, quick-drying liquid eyeliner
  • Humidity/sweat-resistant and waterproof
  • Precise lines as well as thick, dramatic strokes
  • Poor longevity
  • Requires several swipes, so application takes time

When you have wrinkled eyelids, you would rather use a micro-tip instead of fat-tip liners. The latter, no doubt, is very hard to control on wrinkled surfaces. So the micro-tip of this best waterproof liquid eyeliner is such a relief to work with in that it’s precise even on uneven, wrinkled skin.

Yet it’s packed with color pigments for creating thick and saturated strokes!

Truly waterproof and smudge-proof, the Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner by stila can be used to build on multiple layers to get that perfect eye makeup look you have in mind.

5. L’Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner

L’Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner
  • Tug-free, waterproof eyeliner
  • Formulated with mineral pigments for sensitive eyes
  • Precise, easy application that stays smudge-resistant
  • Ergonomic rubber grip also helps add precision/definition
  • Very soft pencil tip breaks easily
  • Not easy to remove

Age Perfect is the name of this mineral-pigmented eyeliner by L’Oreal Paris. The formula is waterproof and of course very gentle because it’s made using skin-caring ingredients such as minerals and vitamins.

The application is easy, precise, and tug-free not just because of the satin-glide liner formula itself but also because the pencil features a very comfortable rubber grip that too makes way for an easy, smooth glide, which is great for you if you’re getting older.

6. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
  • 24/7 waterproof eyeliner pencil (in many colors)
  • Easy, quick to glide on and take off
  • Smudge-free, even if you nap or cry
  • Super creamy and soft plus it dries very quickly
  • Contains moisturizing and hydrating ingredients
  • Too soft, thus tip doesn’t remain sharp for too long
  • Built-in sharpener shaves away excessively

First of all, choose whatever color or colors you like (gold glitter, whiskey matte, bourbon, deep end metallic shimmer, roxy metallic glitter, etc.), there are plenty at your disposal.  And second of all, this is the best eyeliner for mature hooded eyes.

So if you have hooded, crepey, and/or even oily lids, this waterproof pencil eyeliner is right up your alley. Even if you take a nap with this liner on, that line/stroke stays put. The shimmery shades are quite silky and they build well, which looks very flattering on aging skin.

But all colors glide on incredibly smoothly, so no tugging or pulling or any such irritation that thin, delicate, crinkled skin doesn’t like. And every shade/finish adds enough natural-looking color as well as depth without being too dramatic.

And here’s something new and totally amazing, especially if your skin needs extra care and attention. This eyeliner is also enriched with hydrating ingredients such as cottonseed oil, jojoba oil, and Vitamin E.

7. Estee Lauder Eye Care Double Wear Stay In Place Eye Pencil

Estee Lauder Eye Care Double Wear Stay In Place Eye Pencil
  • Long-wear eyeliner pencil even in hot weather
  • Very creamy, so glides on very smoothly
  • Dual-ended with built-in smudger
  • Takes the shortest time to dry and remains smudge-proof
  • Doesn’t give you a blendable line

Now here’s the best long-lasting eyeliner for mature eyes that’s also water-resistant and takes only a few seconds to set it. It’s an ultra-creamy and sheer formula that has no trouble gliding on, even if you have aging skin and eyes.

Women over 50 years of age have absolutely no issues creating a clean, well-defined line on both the upper lid and lower lash. Everything stays smudge-free, and this applies to the color pigments too that stay true for the longest time.

8. Clinique Quickliner for Eyes

Clinique Quickliner for Eyes
  • Goes on and stays on for long easily
  • Silky, soft pencil (smudge and water resistant)
  • Dries in only 60 seconds
  • Not entirely waterproof of course
  • Too soft tip keeps breaking all the time

Goes on very, very smoothly. So easy to glide on. Defines mature, aging eyes with a lot of ease. Stays on smear-free. These are the many praises and compliments Clinique’s quite expensive eyeliner has received.

The color is all kinds of resistant – smudge-resistant, water-resistant, and even transfer-resistant. And all it takes is just 60 seconds to settle, that’s the length of time you’ve got to blend the line if that’s what your eye makeup requires you to do.

9. Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil

Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil
  • Creamy pencil eyeliner glides on very smoothly
  • Mild light diffusers make eyes look whiter
  • Safe, gentle for sensitive and mature eyes
  • Infused with skin-nourishing shea butter and olive oil
  • Contoured smudger and sharpener included
  • Not the best for thin lines/strokes
  • The tip doesn’t sharpen very easily (useless sharpener)

Presenting one of the best drugstore eyeliners that is super-affordable, so you don’t really have to spend big bucks on brands like Clinique, Estee Lauder, Bobbi Brown, etc. if you want something smudge-proof. Also, Neutrogena is a dermatologist tested and recommended brand!

As for the Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil, it stays on even if you have watery eyes. That means this liner beats even those that are “advertised” as hypoallergenic.

It’s a creamy formula, no doubt. But what’s unique here is that it’s highly nourishing too with hydrating ingredients like rainforest shea butter and olive oil. And that’s just what aging skin demands!

10. Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner

Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner
  • Water-resistant eyeliner with all-day lasting power
  • Powder + cream blend for smooth application
  • Applicator brush built into lid, thus pencil-like easy glide 
  • Might smear if you have very oily lids

With the power of coco glycerides, smoothing this eyeliner the most easily becomes possible. Mystikol here is a powder-based liner, not pencil, liquid, or gel. And if you’re under the impression that powder is just going to create a big, huge mess, you’re wrong. And I’m certain that you’re glad to be wrong here.

The highly functional applicator brush has a very creamy consistency, so you don’t have to worry about an easy, clean application (it’s just like applying pencil eyeliner). Plus, you get to experiment with various colors like amethyst, dark topaz, onyx, and smoky quartz.

Should Older Women Wear Eyeliner?

Should Older Women Wear Eyeliner?

As a woman over 50 or 60 years of age, you can put on any kind of makeup you like, no doubt about that. However, the best way to go about is to choose the right ‘type’ of makeup products for your mature, aging skin. Only then do your makeup looks look flattering and well-finished.

As you age, your skin is bound to go through changes, both visible and underneath. For example, you skin on the upper eyelids begins to thin out and crinkle.

For that reason and that reason only you should change the way you care for your skin and also the way you choose and apply your makeup. So avoid stretching your thin eyelids at the time of application. This is why you need an eyeliner that glides on smoothly as well as fills in those wrinkles (i.e. liquid-based liner).

As for should older women experiment with different eye makeup looks? I’d say why not just keep it simple and avoid colors and looks you have never tried. For instance, avoid wearing eyeliner on your lower lids as that can make the eyes appear to be bottom-heavy and smaller, so they look older and more tired.

But, at the same time, no harm in experimenting either. If it doesn’t end up looking good, just wipe it off and nobody will ever know.

Different Types of Eyeliner – Which Eyeliner Is Best for Mature Eyes?

The pencil liner you’ve been using all these years is now starting to feel dry, leaves creases. Hence, it’s not easier anymore to apply. This means time to use a different form of eyeliner that’s more suitable for your aging or mature skin and lids.

1. Pencil Eyeliner

This is the most popular kind of eyeliner because of how easy and quick it is to apply. Pencil glides on very, very smoothly. And you get all sorts of colors – purple, green, blue, etc. So it’s a good way to venture into new territory in terms of experimenting with different shades and looks.

Tips to Apply Eyeliner Pencil On Mature Eyes

Just remember one very useful tip for when applying eyeliner pencil, sharpen that tip before application. A well-sharpened point is obviously easier to work with plus it keeps your makeup hygienic. And use a mirror with high magnification. Place it a little below your chin for an angled view that ensures you don’t tug or pull on the eyes.

‘Feathery strokes’ is the way to go with pencil eyeliner. Hold the pencil horizontally and stroke along the very base of the top lashes.

Don’t apply till the end of the lash if you have droopy eyes to avoid making them look dull, tired, or sad. Instead, stop a little before the end to create that perfect “uplifted” or perky look. And then soften the line using your finger or a brush or cotton bud.

As for putting on eyeliner in your lower lash line, that might add some definition. For that, hold the liner pencil vertically this time with the mirror placed or held in the front. And then run the line along that base of the bottom lash very softly.

2. Liquid Eyeliner

Now liquid eyeliners are longer-lasting because of the presence of stronger pigments in them. However, the tricky part is the application itself. You have to practice A LOT before you actually get it right. But you can use the fine brush applicator that comes with the liner for adding definition. Also, unfortunately, liquid liners are not available in multiple colors.

Tips to Apply Liquid Eyeliner On Mature Eyes

Before application, remove any excess liquid from the brush left over from previous uses. Now begin applying the liner by holding that brush horizontally. Run the line across the base of the lashes (easier said than done, right?).

The best part about liquid eyeliners is that they bring about a lot of definition since the color of the liner is much denser to make aging or mature eyes and their lashes look fuller.

3. Gel Eyeliner

Once again, this type’s tricky to apply too. After all, how thick the line is going to be depends on how you apply the eyeliner, which is something you don’t have to concern yourself with when using a pencil.

But then in comparison to eyeliner pencil, gel-based liners last longer. And since the skin around your eyes, because of age, has thinned out, gliding on gel or liquid liners happens more easily.

Tips to Apply Gel Eyeliner On Mature Eyes

Use a thicker applicator brush for getting a much fuller line. Feel free to smudge that line in order to make your eye makeup look softer and more subtle. And because of the quite strong effect that gel eyeliners have, skip applying it on your lower lashes.

4. Felt-Tip Eyeliner

A blend of liquid and pencil eyeliner, the felt-tip kind is highly pigmented and long-lasting. It’s what many women use for creating an extremely thin line or for that super-adorable cat-eye effect.

Tips to Apply Felt-Tip Eyeliner On Mature Eyes

Tilt the head slightly back (till you can look up the nostrils) when applying felt-tip liner on your eyelids. Hold the eyeliner pen horizontally and, by tapping the tip, run the line along the top lash base.

And just like gel and liquid eyeliner, even this one will make those eyelashes of yours look more defined and fuller.

7 More Very Helpful Eyeliner Tips for Women Over 50

First Apply Eyeliner and Then Eyeshadow

Everyone has their own unique way of wearing makeup. Nevertheless, it’s highly recommended by cosmetics and beauty experts to first apply eyeliner and then put on eyeshadow. So in case you make any mistakes with your liner, those errors will seem less tragic and also easier to correct.

This is the order women generally follow – eye base (in your case, that can be the best eye primer for mature skin, so your liner and shadow stay on crease-free for a much longer time), then eyeliner (blend the liner using your fingers or a brush), and finally, your choice of eyeshadow color (experiment with a shimmery finish for a hint of glam!).

Choose the Right Type of Eyeliner (and it should be waterproof too!)

We can debate on this as much as possible, the undeniable truth is that gel and liquid liners are much easier to handle during application. For aging, mature skin, these kinds of eyeliners tend to glide on oh-so-smoothly!

But if you still prefer traditional pencil eyeliner, then make sure that the formula is soft and creamy to prevent skips and gaps.

And lastly, no matter what type of eyeliner, it should be waterproof for a smudge-free effect. Waterproof liner is a must for women over 50 since it’s more likely to stay put throughout the whole day.

Apply In Small Strokes Between Your Lashes

Look down into your mirror and bring the pencil eyeliner from below instead of above your eye-line. Use small strokes and apply between the lashes, not over them. You start from the outside edge and go along slowly inward to that inner corner of your eye. Small movements, always remember that.

You can pull the eye gently and just slightly toward the outer side while working the liner. Also make sure that you tilt the head back during application (till you can look up the nostrils). And one last thing, holding the pencil horizontally really helps when it comes to creating a smooth, even line across your lid (avoid pointing the eyeliner pencil at you).

Always Blend, Blend, Blend

You’ll see that if you blend those edges of the eyeliner with the help of a narrow, stiff brush, it will create a very neat and clean smoky finish that looks soft, minus any solid edges. Focus more on blending the outer part of the liner while keeping that inner line narrow.

Know When to NOT Apply Eyeliner Under Your Eyes

This is when dark circles are a part of your eyes. At such times, putting liner below the eyes is only bound to draw more attention to them. You can instead compromise a little – meaning put some liner only on that outer edge and then blend using a brush.

Choose Eyeliner Colors Very Carefully

Black color liner appears a bit too harsh if your natural skin tone is on the fairer side or if you have mature, aging eyes. Instead, opt for grey eyeliner or soft brown, taupe, royal blue, or deep plum. These seem like more suitable and pleasant choices for daily wear.

As for women with a darker complexion, black eyeliner works for them because it doesn’t look as harsh. And of course, do not hesitate to try out colors like navy and purple if you wish, you never know what might just look good on you!

But what’s sure to complement mature eyes is a white liner or even nude color. When applied to the water or lower lash line, it can really make your eyes look bigger and perkier.

Use A High Magnifying Mirror

Now wouldn’t it be better for you if the mirror you’re using has higher magnification so you can see more clearly? But then go about lingering over your “flaws” and “imperfections” in front of this mirror. Just use it for when you’re applying your makeup.

Conclusion – So Does Eyeliner Make Mature Eyes Look Younger or Older?

Eyeliner will only make your eyes look older or smaller if your technique is not right. A smooth application using a liquid-based or gel-based liner, on the contrary, adds more definition. Along with making the eyes look more youthful, radiant, and brighter.

But if you already have large eyes, then scale down the size simply by lining your bottom lashes too. And use eyeliner shades like gray, brown, or taupe.

Once again, it’s all about technique and what type of eyeliner you choose.

Leave a Comment